Anchor Inn & Cottages

Eight cottages and inn rooms along Periwinkle Way place Anchor Inn at the quiet residential spine of Sanibel Island, where the street runs parallel to both the Gulf and the bay rather than leading directly to either.

The property draws repeat visitors for its unhurried scale — no lobby crowd, no conference wing. Sanibel's shell-strewn beaches sit within a short bike ride, and the Ding Darling Wildlife Refuge entrance is reachable in under ten minutes along the dedicated island cycle path.

With a 9.6 guest rating across 28 reviews, the inn earns consistent praise for attentive, personal service that larger Gulf Coast resorts cannot replicate. Periwinkle Way itself hosts the island's main cluster of cafes and independent shops, all walkable from the front door.